Ice Cream Siesta Key

The Orange Octopus at Captain Curt’s Village

Captain Curt’s Village: Home of the Best Ice Cream Siesta Key

Going to the beach in Florida means a few things—white sand, crashing waves, and delicious fresh seafood. However, beachlife is also about getting hand-scooped ice cream. There’s nothing better than racing against the heat to finish your cone before it all melts onto the ground at Ice Cream Siesta Key.

While you can visit any creamery or ice cream shop, we believe that the Orange Octopus has the best ice cream on Siesta Key. Best of all, it’s part of Captain Curt’s Village, meaning you can spend practically all day here. From your morning cup of coffee to lunch and dinner at one of the top seafood restaurants in Siesta Key, we have it all.

Orange Octopus Ice Cream Siesta Key: The Best Sarasota Ice Cream Shop

What makes great ice cream? Is it the ingredients? The selection of unique flavors? Or is it the people serving the ice cream to you?

At The Orange Octopus Siesta Key, we take care to fulfill every aspect of delivering a superior ice cream experience.

All of our ice cream is made in small batches, meaning we use high-quality ingredients that you can taste and see. If a flavor says it has fudge or peanut butter or espresso in it, that means we added those elements by hand. Big chains use synthetic flavors, but we use the real deal.

When it comes to ice cream flavors, we can satisfy every taste bud, even for those picky eaters in your family. With 24 options available, you can go nuts with your selection (while adding nuts on top).

What kind of ice cream speaks to you? Butterscotch Blast? Gator Tracks? Strawberry Cheesecake? If you’re looking for dairy-free desserts, we have an assortment of fresh and fruity sorbets so you aren’t left out.

Simple flavors and ingredients, plus friendly staff that serves you with a smile. That’s the Orange Octopus Ice Cream way.

Why Visit Orange Octopus for the Best Ice Cream Siesta Key Experience?

You don’t have to be an ice cream fiend to find something to enjoy at our creamery. In addition to hand-scooped perfection, we also offer milkshakes and smoothies so you can enjoy your dessert without making a mess.

Best of all, we’re part of Captain Curt’s Village. So, no matter when you get a craving for ice cream, we’re always there for you.

Do you want to visit the best Siesta Key tiki bar? Try the Sniki Tiki and enjoy some delicious island-inspired cocktails!

Do you want to sample the best seafood Siesta Key has to offer, including our world-famous clam chowder? Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar has you covered without forcing you to break the bank.

Do you want to buy high-quality souvenirs for your friends and family back home? Check out our extensive gift shop and find the perfect option for anyone who loves the beach!

Best of all, everything is within strolling distance of our ice cream shop, so you never have to venture far.

Get the Best Siesta Key Ice Cream at Captain Curt’s Village

Ice cream is as much a part of the beach experience as sand and surf. When you get the best ice cream Siesta Key has to offer, the world stops. All that matters is the next lick (or spoonful), and you can literally feel all your worries melt away.

Visit the Orange Octopus Siesta Key ice cream shop and see why we’re a family destination.

Frequently Asked Questions - Ice Cream Siesta Key

What makes the Orange Octopus the best ice cream Siesta Key has to offer?

The Orange Octopus stands out as the best ice cream Siesta Key has to offer due to its use of high-quality ingredients, small batch production, and a wide variety of flavors. Each scoop is crafted with care, ensuring a superior taste experience.

Does the Orange Octopus offer any non-ice cream desserts in Siesta Key?

Yes, in addition to their exceptional ice cream, the Orange Octopus in Siesta Key offers milkshakes and smoothies, providing a variety of refreshing options to enjoy on a hot day.

Can I get free samples at the Orange Octopus ice cream shop in Siesta Key?

Absolutely! The Orange Octopus in Siesta Key is happy to provide free samples to help you decide which delicious flavor to choose, ensuring you find your perfect treat.

Is the ice cream at the Orange Octopus in Siesta Key made with real ingredients?

Yes, all ice cream at the Orange Octopus in Siesta Key is made in small batches using real ingredients. If a flavor includes fudge, peanut butter, or espresso, it’s made with the real thing, not synthetic flavors.

Are there dairy-free options available at the Orange Octopus in Siesta Key?

 Yes, the Orange Octopus in Siesta Key offers a variety of dairy-free sorbets, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a refreshing treat, regardless of dietary restrictions.

What makes the Orange Octopus a family-friendly ice cream shop in Siesta Key?

 The Orange Octopus in Siesta Key is a family-friendly ice cream shop because of its welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and a wide range of flavors that cater to all tastes, making it a perfect spot for families to relax and enjoy a treat together.

Why should I choose the Orange Octopus for ice cream in Siesta Key over other ice cream shops? 

Choosing the Orange Octopus for ice cream in Siesta Key ensures you’ll enjoy high-quality, hand-scooped ice cream made with real ingredients, a diverse flavor selection, and a convenient location within Captain Curt’s Village, providing an all-around exceptional experience.

1200 Old Stickney Point Rd,
Sarasota, Florida, 34242

Directions »